Theological textbooks

Ben has a teaching job (congratulations, Ben!), and asked on Facebook about textbooks for introductory theology courses. I started writing a comment, which rapidly became an essay; but it seemed a question of more general interest, so I thought I’d move my thoughts here…

Which is the best textbook? I can’t answer this without answering several prior questions about the nature of the course, how it fits into the wider curriculum, the identity of the students, &c., &c. I’d start by thinking about these:

1. What do I want to achieve in this course? (Not ‘learning outcomes’, although including those as well):

  • Do I want students to have a basic understanding of the major loci of theology?
  • Do I want them to have a detailed knowledge of certain key loci (Trinity & Christology, say)?
  • Do I want to introduce them to the breadth of the theological tradition?
  • Do I want them to be seriously grounded in one tradition (Wesleyan; Reformed; Pentecostal; neo-Thomist)?
  • Do I want them to face up to modern critiques of theology and possible answers?
  • Do I want them thoroughly grounded in the patristic debates and ecumenical decisions?
  • Do I want them to understand the nature of theological claims and argument?
  • Do I want them to be excited about the possibilities of theology?
  • Do I want them alive to majority world and gender issues concerning justice, and how these impact theology?
  • Do I want to emphasise the ethical and social implications of theology?

These all pull in different directions. I grew up on the ‘worthy but dull’ tradition of evangelical textbooks – we had Erickson, but McGrath and Grudem are now more popular. For a while, I reacted badly, emphasising interest and excitement over content (if they’re up to it, give them Gunton’s Cambridge Companion to Christian Doctrine, and let Jenson and Hauerwas provoke them with idiosyncratic views). When Colin Gunton, Murray Rae and I wrote a textbook, it was designed explicitly for a course on theological method, and with an eye to introducing people to the major voices of the theological tradition. The thing is, you can’t be both comprehensive and deep, both balanced and provocative; in the space of one module including one thing means excluding something else (or failing to do either…). Only when you know what the course is aiming to achieve can you choose a textbook that will help, rather than hinder, your aims.

2. What does the wider curriculum look like? What opportunities for supplementing or reinforcing your course are there?

Are all the students doing level 1 church history at the same time? If so, what is it about? If it is patristics (it often is, rightly or wrongly), you can choose to focus on ecumenical debates over Trinity and Christology, and expect some reinforcement between the courses, or you can choose to go light on the ecumenical debates, trusting your colleague to give the students the things you are skipping in her lectures/seminars.

How much other theology are the students forced to do? How much are they able to do? If yours is the only compulsory course, what is so central that every student should have met it? If there is another compulsory course in year 2, what does it contain? What do students need to know to engage with that course effectively (you need to give it to them)? What are they going to do in detail there, allowing you to go light on it? Here in St Andrews, Alan Torrance teaches our introductory module. He does a stunningly good job of exciting students about the possibilities and relevance of theology, and of introducing them to certain absolutely central concepts and debates. I get them in the second year; knowing this background, I feel constrained to give them a survey course that introduces most doctrinal loci and the general shape of them. The broader curriculum has to fit together.

3. Who are your students?

This question includes intellectual ability; previous academic achievement; faith commitments; vocational intentions; age, gender and ethnic profile; and some other things. I first taught theology in Spurgeons College, a Baptist college for ordinands. The students there varied extraordinarily widely in intellect and academic background, but were united by a broadly evangelical faith and a commitment to the Christian ministry. Here in St Andrews, the students are uniformly intellectually able and academically well-prepared, but vary significantly in their beliefs and intentions. In Spurgeons, I needed a textbook (or a suite of textbooks) that would interest recent Oxford graduates and be accessible to ex-bricklayers, but I could assume a particular angle on the subject. Here, I can assume a certain level of ability to engage with a difficult text, but I cannot use anything that presumes its readers are Christian.

After answering all these questions, I know what sort of book I am looking for: the academic level; the content; the approach. Inevitably, the perfect book doesn’t exist. Compromise. Or write it.


  1. Andy Goodliff
    Dec 5, 2008

    ‘The Making of Christian Theology’ that you, Colin and Brian Horne taught at King’s was a fantastic introduction to theology …

    In terms of textbooks, i think you want a textbook that the student will still use after the first year … there’s nothing worse than buying a book which becomes useless in the future … that’s why the cambridge companion to doctrine and mike higton’s new SCM christian doctrine would both be on my list.

  2. CTN
    Dec 5, 2008

    Thanks Steve! I can vouch for Alan Torrance – I studied abroad in St. Andrews in 2004 and sat in his introductory theology class, and he was really good at getting us to start making systematic connections in their theology.

  3. Ben Myers
    Dec 5, 2008

    Thanks, Steve: this is very helpful, even if you steadfastly (and wisely) refused to recommend any particular text!

  4. Neil B
    Dec 5, 2008

    I’m with Andy here in that a good introductory text book is likely to be one you use afterwards (and if you want to know I still occasionally reach for McGrath’s introductory theology & reader and IVP’s New Dictionary of Theology). Though now I think I’d go for Cambridge Companion as the book to encourage every student to read.

    However, as I look back on my time at college a good module bibliography was a greater key to learning than a single text book. What opened this first year student’s eyes was the variety of voices and opinions to be read.

  5. Steve H
    Dec 5, 2008

    I’m not so convinced about a book you keep on using. I tend not to set specific textbooks for courses (Neil’s point about a wide bibliography…), but if the book is central to the module, and you are investing 200 hours of their time in a module (what we expect in St Andrews at subhonours level), then spending £20 on a book, is not such a big investment, even if you throw it away the day after the exam.

  6. Andy Goodliff
    Dec 6, 2008

    of you course you don’t mean ‘throw it away’ but pass it on to someone else or give to 2nd hand bookshop. 🙂

  7. Steve H
    Dec 6, 2008

    @Ben: when you start teaching, and particularly marking, you will become very used to people answering the question they’d have like you to have asked, rather than the one you actually did ask…

  8. Jon
    Dec 6, 2008

    Text books will dull your mind…

    The best lecturers give the students the desire to explore further – the textbook is for the people who want to pass the module – the rest of the theological tradition is for those who want to imbibe the module…

    That’s why St Andrews is, without doubt, the best theological faculty in the whole world!

  9. Ronnie Hall
    Dec 8, 2008

    I’d go for ‘faith seeking understanding’ by Migliore. It is Reformed but balanced. The Fictional Dialogues between Barth, Rahner and Pannenberg are excellent.

  10. Fatimah Alashour
    Jul 7, 2010

    Hi, I’m a student at Toledo University
    If you don’t mind I want to use one of your picture articles (The Conundrum of Choosing a Theology Textbook) in my presentation. I would be grateful.
    Fatimah Alashour


  1. The Conundrum of Choosing a Theology Textbook « Theology Forum - [...] Stephen Holmes (University of St. Andrews) wrote an exceedingly helpful post not long ago on choosing a textbook for…

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

get facebook like button